Photo Credit: Mike Lucia
Well it wasn’t fake news, that’s for sure. It took all the resources we could throw at it - with help from across the state and the country - to fight back the very real, swiftly moving, voracious Kinkade fire. Winds were against us, and the terrain made it extremely difficult, but in the end determination, experience and bravery were on our side.
Even the evacuations - widespread, emotionally upsetting, and costly for many - were by any standard known for this kind of calamity remarkable for how well they unfolded. In Healdsburg alone, only 84 residents out of 11,000 refused to leave in order to let the firefighters do their job unfettered. Families, friends and strangers opened their homes; shelters and organizations like World Central Kitchen and Corazón Healdsburg housed the homeless and fed the first responders. Incredibly, thanks in great part to coordinated efforts by Cal Fire and remarkable teamwork between City, Fire and Police Departments, there was no loss of life. How we got through Kinkade as a community, the outpouring of concern and care, is something I hope will not be lost as we eagerly return to our lives in this beautiful place.
While there is no making light of the destruction, property loss, and fear for life this fire generated, there are larger questions now for those of us picking up where we left off during harvest, reopening our businesses, restaurants, shops, tasting rooms and vineyards. How do we proceed if this is - as it’s being touted everywhere - as ‘The New Normal’?
Normal, as compared to what? California has a wild rugged history we take pride in rewriting every time tragedy strikes. Climate change - call it what you want… something has changed, and drastically - will no doubt bring increased challenges. We have populated out instead of up, increasing our use of fossil fuels, been forced to put our lives into the hands of utilities that are run for profit before safety, mismanaged our forests and strained our water resources. It’s important to take stock, to ask what Northern California can do to mitigate the challenges ahead, but calling something which threatens to turn our beautiful landscape into a disaster movie ‘normal’ doesn’t seem quite right. Is acquiescing the best we can do?
Tip the country, the old saying goes, and whatever crazy thing isn’t tethered will roll down and stop here. My father was fond of this saying even though he came to California of his own volition; the same inexorable drive spurred the gold rush, the film industry, aerospace, tech. I knew nothing about farming when I homesteaded on a ridge in Philo with two small boys three decades ago. Geoff, Lukka and I knew nothing about restaurants when we built Barndiva and naively but passionately joined the farm to table movement. The thing about California and the folks who tend to set up camp here is that – for good or ill – it inspires schemes and dreams that have always found a home in the West.
But it’s important to understand we came into a landscape that has been here long before us. A professor I worked with in film school at UCLA had been burned out of Malibu – in the appropriately named Carbon Canyon- four times. He told me this almost as an aside one evening as we sipped tequila looking out over the chaparral: “It needs to burn, to cleanse itself from time to time.” The way he saw it he had the choice to get out of the way when that happened or lose what it gave him when it was whole, when the coyotes sang their sad poems and the clean dry winds blew, clearing his mind. That was many years ago. Up and down the state we have built too much, love too much of what we have built to move aside and let it burn, though sometimes it may be out of our control. What is in our control is what we must focus on now.
The rueful headlines generated as we fought the Kinkade fire were meant to sell papers and push likes on social media. While the next sensational headlines have already taken their place there is great concern that several years of fires have reached a tipping point that is going to cause great harm to many sectors of our economy. I don’t believe that in the long run people will stop coming to Sonoma County to visit or to live. Not a chance. Because it is a very good life here indeed, a landscape of extraordinary beauty, a phenomenal food shed, great wines, chefs that cook with passion and purpose. It may well flip our tourist seasons, which would not be the most awful thing. The greater issue is how we, as a larger community, move on.
My family was lucky we had our farm to retreat to when evacuation started in Healdsburg and spread to Windsor and Santa Rosa. When the electricity cut out we were still able to cook by propane. We dined by candlelight, and as a talisman, drank fine California wine. By day we picked the last of the apples, put the gardens to sleep for the winter, cleaned far corners of the barn. Incessantly, we checked Twitter for news. By Tuesday, waiting for the second round of red flag winds, we wandered out to the coast, haunting darkened hardware stores looking for generator parts, restaurants for a hot meal. In the town of Mendocino we ran into so many neighbors from Healdsburg it began to feel like a reunion one hadn’t planned on attending but found, in its satisfying sense of camaraderie, oddly comforting. People draw together in times like these. Then they forget.
We should not forget. As we get on with our lives we should move forward with new resolve to ensure we run our businesses and our homes so they are formed to fit a new paradigm of using less, more wisely. It is time to rethink the manner of all development to come, and the way we are set up to run our local economies. If we are private or public stewards of open land we must do better in managing our seasonally volatile terrain.
Photo Credit: Erik Castro
Some fires will not be preventable in the coming years, for those we must plan as they do in the Midwest for hurricanes or tornadoes. Improve lines of emergency communications, support infrastructure necessary for temporary housing and feeding residents. It is most essential we make sure there is adequate support for first responders - we were only able to contain Kinkade because Cal Fire took a proactive tactic in which evacuation was key, allowing strike teams to focus on making a stand to stop the fires and not have to worry about saving lives.
Crucially, despite the fact that no one in positions of authority or power seems to be held accountable for anything anymore, as taxpayers and consumers we must reconsider how California’s resources are being managed. There is no avoiding the fact that some fires, and it’s looking like Kinkade is among them, are preventable. It is time to seriously consider moving a bankrupt PG&E into public ownership, which would not be without its own problems but a step forward in having safety of the citizenry as its primary concern.
Whether it’s political action or the nuanced changes we must now take as individuals as we approach the ‘New Normal,’ we will only continue to thrive in the coming years if we commit to growing a more pluralistic definition of community, town by town by town, building a citizenry less obsessed with their own version of the good life, more invested in a good life for all, one that educates as it moves every income bracket forward. The smoke has cleared. What do we see?
